Old Fashioned Tomato Pie Recipe

⬇ Jump to Recipe

Old Fashioned Tomato Pie is a beloved Southern classic that layers thick-sliced ripe tomatoes, fresh herbs, and a savory cheese-mayo topping inside a golden baked pie crust. It’s the kind of recipe that turns peak-summer tomatoes into something truly unforgettable — deeply savory, creamy, and rich with garden flavor. Perfect for a summer lunch, potluck, or any time you want to make the most of fresh, in-season tomatoes.

Whether you’re cooking for a busy weeknight or a relaxed weekend dinner, this Old Fashioned Tomato Pie Recipe delivers every single time. Keep reading for everything you need — ingredients, step-by-step instructions, tips, and the full recipe card below.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

Ingredients You’ll Need

Here is everything you need to make Old Fashioned Tomato Pie Recipe. Full quantities are in the recipe card below.

• For the Crust:
• 1 pre-made 9-inch deep-dish pie crust (store-bought or homemade), blind-baked
• For the Tomato Layer:
• 3–4 large ripe tomatoes (about 2 lbs / 900g), cored and sliced ¼-inch thick
• 1 tsp salt (for drawing out moisture)
• For the Herb & Onion Layer:
• 3 green onions (scallions), thinly sliced
• 2 cloves garlic, minced
• ¼ cup fresh basil leaves, roughly torn
• 1 tbsp fresh chives, chopped
• ½ tsp black pepper
• ¼ tsp red pepper flakes (optional)
• For the Cheese-Mayo Topping:
• ¾ cup mayonnaise
• 1 cup shredded sharp cheddar cheese
• ½ cup shredded mozzarella cheese
• 1 tbsp Dijon mustard
• 1 tbsp fresh lemon juice
• Garnish:
• 1 tbsp fresh basil, chiffonade
• Pinch of smoked paprika

How to Choose the Best Ingredients

The quality of your ingredients directly impacts the final dish. For Old Fashioned Tomato Pie Recipe, look for the freshest produce available and don’t skip on the key flavoring ingredients — they make all the difference between a good dish and an unforgettable one.

When shopping, prioritize fresh over pre-packaged where possible. Fresh herbs, quality proteins, and ripe produce will elevate the final result considerably compared to their processed or out-of-season alternatives.

How to Make Old Fashioned Tomato Pie Recipe

Follow these steps for perfect results every time. Full details including exact quantities are in the recipe card at the bottom of this post.

1. 1
   Step 1 — Blind Bake the Crust Preheat oven to 375°F (190°C). Fit the pie crust into a 9-inch deep-dish pie dish, crimp the edges, and prick the bottom with a fork. Line with parchment paper, fill with pie weights or dried beans, and bake for 15 minutes. Remove weights and parchment and bake another 5 minutes until lightly golden. Set aside to cool.
2. 2
   Step 2 — Salt and Drain the Tomatoes Arrange tomato slices in a single layer on a wire rack set over a baking sheet. Sprinkle both sides generously with the 1 tsp salt. Let sit for 30–40 minutes. Pat completely dry with paper towels — this step is non-negotiable. Wet tomatoes will make the crust soggy.
3. 3
   Step 3 — Build the Herb Layer In a small bowl, combine the sliced green onions, minced garlic, torn basil, chives, black pepper, and red pepper flakes if using. Toss gently to mix.
4. 4
   Step 4 — Layer the Pie Arrange half the drained tomato slices in a single overlapping layer in the blind-baked crust. Scatter half the herb mixture over the tomatoes. Repeat with the remaining tomatoes and remaining herbs, pressing down gently to compact the layers.
5. 5
   Step 5 — Make and Apply the Topping In a bowl, stir together the mayonnaise, shredded cheddar, shredded mozzarella, Dijon mustard, and lemon juice until well combined. Spread the cheese-mayo mixture evenly over the top of the tomato layers, covering all the way to the crust edges to create a golden seal.
6. 6
   Step 6 — Bake Until Golden and Bubbling Bake at 375°F (190°C) for 30–35 minutes until the top is deeply golden brown and the filling is set and bubbling gently at the edges. If the crust edges brown too fast, tent with foil strips. The topping should look like a golden, cheesy crust — not pale.
7. 7
   Step 7 — Rest and Serve Remove from the oven and let the pie rest on a wire rack for at least 20–30 minutes before slicing. This allows the filling to firm up into clean, sliceable layers. Garnish with fresh basil chiffonade and a pinch of smoked paprika. Serve warm or at room temperature.

Why This Recipe Works

Every step in this recipe is deliberate. The combination of technique and timing creates layers of flavor that build on each other. The seasoning approach ensures every component is properly seasoned rather than relying on salt at the end. The cooking method locks in moisture while developing the exterior texture that makes this dish so satisfying.

The key is following the steps in order and not rushing any stage. Each element of this recipe was tested to work in harmony with the others — skipping or shortcutting any step will affect the final result.

Best Side Dishes to Serve With Old Fashioned Tomato Pie Recipe

Variations to Try

• Dairy-Free: Substitute any dairy ingredients with high-quality plant-based alternatives.
• Gluten-Free: Use certified gluten-free versions of any sauces or seasonings.
• Spicy Version: Add red pepper flakes or a dash of hot sauce to taste.
• Make-Ahead: Prepare components up to 24 hours ahead and assemble before serving.
• Slow Cooker: Adapt for the slow cooker — cook on LOW for 6–8 hours for even deeper flavor.

Storage, Meal Prep & Reheating

Storing Leftovers

Store leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 4 days. The flavors often deepen overnight making leftovers just as satisfying as the fresh dish.

Freezing

This recipe freezes well for up to 3 months. Cool completely before transferring to freezer-safe containers. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before reheating.

Reheating

Reheat gently on the stovetop over medium-low heat or in the microwave covered with a damp paper towel. Add a splash of water or broth if needed to restore moisture. Avoid overheating — gentle and slow preserves the texture best.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Skipping the prep work. Having everything measured and ready before you start makes the cooking process smooth and prevents overcooking while you search for ingredients.
• Rushing the cooking time. Each step has a purpose. Trust the timing and resist the urge to speed things up.
• Not tasting as you go. Adjust seasoning at every stage — waiting until the end means you’ve missed multiple opportunities to build flavor.
• Overcrowding the pan. Cook in batches if needed. Overcrowding creates steam rather than the browning and caramelization that builds flavor.

Nutritional Information

Per serving (based on 4 servings):

Serving & Presentation Tips

• Garnish at the last moment. Fresh herbs and finishing elements go on right before serving for maximum visual impact and freshness.
• Warm your serving dishes. A warm plate keeps the food at the right temperature longer — simply run hot water over the plate for 30 seconds and dry before plating.
• Less is more. Clean, intentional plating always looks more impressive than an overcrowded plate.

Frequently Asked Questions

You Might Also Love

Final Thoughts

This Old Fashioned Tomato Pie Recipe has become a go-to for good reason — it delivers on every level. The flavor is deep and satisfying, the technique is straightforward, and the results are consistently impressive whether you’re cooking for yourself on a Tuesday or feeding a table full of people on a weekend.

Once you’ve made it the first time, you’ll understand exactly why it works so well. The combination of well-seasoned ingredients, proper technique, and a little patience produces something genuinely greater than the sum of its parts.

Make it this week and let us know how it turned out — leave a comment below and tell us what you served alongside. We read every single one. 🍽️

Easy

Comfort Food Classics
Old Fashioned Tomato Pie Recipe

Old Fashioned Tomato Pie Recipe

Old Fashioned Tomato Pie is a beloved Southern classic that layers thick-sliced ripe tomatoes, fresh herbs, and a savory cheese-mayo topping inside a golden baked pie crust. It’s the kind of recipe that turns peak-summer tomatoes into something truly unforgettable — deeply savory, creamy, and rich with garden flavor. Perfect for a summer lunch, potluck, or any time you want to make the most of fresh, in-season tomatoes.

15 minPrep

30 minCook

45 minTotal

4Servings

~420Calories

Ingredients

• For the Crust:
• 1 pre-made 9-inch deep-dish pie crust (store-bought or homemade), blind-baked
• For the Tomato Layer:
• 3–4 large ripe tomatoes (about 2 lbs / 900g), cored and sliced ¼-inch thick
• 1 tsp salt (for drawing out moisture)
• For the Herb & Onion Layer:
• 3 green onions (scallions), thinly sliced
• 2 cloves garlic, minced
• ¼ cup fresh basil leaves, roughly torn
• 1 tbsp fresh chives, chopped
• ½ tsp black pepper
• ¼ tsp red pepper flakes (optional)
• For the Cheese-Mayo Topping:
• ¾ cup mayonnaise
• 1 cup shredded sharp cheddar cheese
• ½ cup shredded mozzarella cheese
• 1 tbsp Dijon mustard
• 1 tbsp fresh lemon juice
• Garnish:
• 1 tbsp fresh basil, chiffonade
• Pinch of smoked paprika

Instructions

1. 1
   Step 1 — Blind Bake the Crust Preheat oven to 375°F (190°C). Fit the pie crust into a 9-inch deep-dish pie dish, crimp the edges, and prick the bottom with a fork. Line with parchment paper, fill with pie weights or dried beans, and bake for 15 minutes. Remove weights and parchment and bake another 5 minutes until lightly golden. Set aside to cool.
2. 2
   Step 2 — Salt and Drain the Tomatoes Arrange tomato slices in a single layer on a wire rack set over a baking sheet. Sprinkle both sides generously with the 1 tsp salt. Let sit for 30–40 minutes. Pat completely dry with paper towels — this step is non-negotiable. Wet tomatoes will make the crust soggy.
3. 3
   Step 3 — Build the Herb Layer In a small bowl, combine the sliced green onions, minced garlic, torn basil, chives, black pepper, and red pepper flakes if using. Toss gently to mix.
4. 4
   Step 4 — Layer the Pie Arrange half the drained tomato slices in a single overlapping layer in the blind-baked crust. Scatter half the herb mixture over the tomatoes. Repeat with the remaining tomatoes and remaining herbs, pressing down gently to compact the layers.
5. 5
   Step 5 — Make and Apply the Topping In a bowl, stir together the mayonnaise, shredded cheddar, shredded mozzarella, Dijon mustard, and lemon juice until well combined. Spread the cheese-mayo mixture evenly over the top of the tomato layers, covering all the way to the crust edges to create a golden seal.
6. 6
   Step 6 — Bake Until Golden and Bubbling Bake at 375°F (190°C) for 30–35 minutes until the top is deeply golden brown and the filling is set and bubbling gently at the edges. If the crust edges brown too fast, tent with foil strips. The topping should look like a golden, cheesy crust — not pale.
7. 7
   Step 7 — Rest and Serve Remove from the oven and let the pie rest on a wire rack for at least 20–30 minutes before slicing. This allows the filling to firm up into clean, sliceable layers. Garnish with fresh basil chiffonade and a pinch of smoked paprika. Serve warm or at room temperature.

📝 Charlotte’s Notes

Read the full recipe before you start. Having everything prepped and ready makes the process smooth and the result consistent.

Taste and adjust seasoning at every stage — this is the single most important habit you can develop as a cook.

Recipe by Charlotte · Sip Savory Recipes

🖨 Print
📌 Save to Pinterest